when i first started baking (decades ago. decades. ouch.), i couldn’t make a chocolate chip cookie that didn’t resemble a cow pie. the cow pie isn’t a very appealing image, i know, but it very aptly described their appearance – wide, flat and bumpy. looking back, i’m sure this propensity to spread had more to do with my technique than it did with the recipe. too soft butter (i probably used margarine in those early days – shudder.), too hot an oven, over beating the dough, using super-dark cookie sheets…all my own missteps. i had always viewed my cow pie cookies as inferiors to their puffy, golden, cakey cousins, and have been disappointed with just about every single batch i’ve ever made, until last night.
TDHH knows all he has to do is utter the words “i wish we could have some cookies/cake/brownies tonight” and i’ll have my apron tied and ingredients out before he actually finishes his sentence. i love baking that much.
so last night he requested chocolate chip cookies. i had already started mentally perusing my recipes, wondering which would yield the least cowpieish cookies, when he clarified that he was hoping for thin, buttery chocolate chip cookies. a sincere request for cow pies? really?
i recalled a recipe which met this very description and used fridge-cold butter*, a specification which makes these ideal for a spontaneous treat. i had scrawled it into my recipe book years ago, and if i recall correctly, it belongs to david lebovitz. now, i don’t know if his recipe was meant to produce cow pies, but it does for me, reliably, and i had always considered this a drawback until i came to my cookie senses last night.
these cookies are very thin and golden and studded with dark chocolate chips. they are buttery and sugary and vanilla-y. they are at once crispy and chewy. what in the world is inferior about that? these cookies are, in a word, sublime – sublime enough to have made me appreciate every bit of their cowpieness and to have been deemed worthy of a spot near the top of my imaginary cookie recipe podium.
*don’t be bothered by this. it works. really.
• • •
david lebovitz’s (cow pie) {chocolate chip cookies} (i probably don’t need to restate this, but they’re from david lebovitz)
makes about 2 dozen
1/2 cup granulated sugar
1/2 cup packed light brown sugar
8 tbsp (1/2 cup) cold unsalted butter, cut into 1/2″ pieces
1 large egg
1 tsp pure vanilla extract
1/2 tsp baking soda
1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
1/4 tsp salt
1 1/2 cups semi-sweet chocolate chips (i used a combination of bittersweet chips, fudge chips and semi-sweet chips)
1 cup walnuts or pecans, toasted and chopped (we weren’t in the mood for nuts)
•preheat oven to 300°f. beat the sugars and cold butter until smooth (i used my stand mixer – this is one you couldn’t do by hand). mix in egg and vanilla and baking soda (adding the baking soda like this seemed weird to me).
•stir flour and salt together, then stir into the butter mixture. stir in the chocolate chips (and nuts, if using).
•scoop batter into 2 tbsp balls and place 4″ apart on cookie sheet (i wonder if they would have spread less if i didn’t use parchment?). bake for 18 minutes (mine were done in 15). cool somewhat before handling as they’re fragile when hot. enjoy!
• • •